May 11, 2015

6 huge changes for the Common App in 2015-16



Although months away, the debut of the 2015-16 Common Application will include six huge changes reflecting recommendations made by counselors and applicants over the past two years—since the “new” Common App came online in August 2013.

As he took over responsibility for day-to-day operations, the Common App's interim CEO Paul Mott has repeatedly underscored his desire to remove instances of “pointless friction” in how the application is perceived and actually performs for applicants, recommenders and member institutions paying for the service.  

This year, the Common App looks for a membership of about 600 colleges and universities many of which prefer to keep administrative headaches to a minimum, while taking full advantage of the increasing numbers of applicants the Common App has attracted in the past.

And as administrative staff continues to solicit and respond to concerns and suggestions for improvement from among various stakeholder groups, the Common App has already announced the six important changes for next year:


  • No essay.  Starting with the 2015-16 application year, Common App member colleges will have the choice of whether or not to require the Common App personal statement.  If the personal statement is required for a particular college, that requirement will be enforced during the submission process.  In other words, students will NOT be able to submit an application without this element.  For colleges not requiring a personal statement, applicants will be given the option to submit if they wish to do so.

  • Unlimited essay edits.  For the first time, the Common App will place no restrictions on the number of times a student may edit or change their personal statement.   Similar to other parts of the application, the personal statement may revised or altogether changed with every submission. By lifting this restriction, the Common App effectively gives students the ability to “tailor” personal statements to individual colleges—a very nice way to demonstrate interest in and knowledge of a particular institution.

  • Print preview anytime.  In the coming year, applicants will be able to “preview” the completed portions of their application—screen by screen—at any point, not just as part of the submission process.  By clicking the new preview button located on each page of the application, students will be able to generate a printable view of completed sections of the applications.  Note that if the applicant has not yet entered any information into a particular section, that section will appear blank on the preview.

  • New prompts.   After assessing feedback from various quarters, the Common App completely deleted one prompt, added a new option and tinkered in minor ways with the other four personal statement choices.  The new prompts are as follows (changes are marked in italics):

    1. Some students have a background, identity, interest, or talent that is so meaningful they believe their application would be incomplete without it. If this sounds like you, then please share your story.
    2. The lessons we take from failure can be fundamental to later success. Recount an incident or time when you experienced failure. How did it affect you, and what did you learn from the experience?
    3. Reflect on a time when you challenged a belief or idea. What prompted you to act? Would you make the same decision again?
    4. Describe a problem you’ve solved or a problem you’d like to solve. It can be an intellectual challenge, a research query, an ethical dilemma-anything that is of personal importance, no matter the scale. Explain its significance to you and what steps you took or could be taken to identify a solution.
    5. Discuss an accomplishment or event, formal or informal, that marked your transition from childhood to adulthood within your culture, community, or family.
  • Optional recommendations.  During the coming year, member colleges and universities will have the option of whether to require any recommendations.  Previously, membership standards required institutions to ask for at least one recommendation from “a school-based counselor or academic teacher.”  For 2015-16, this will not be the case.
  • No penalties for competing applications.  One of the biggest changes for member institutions is a new pricing plan that removes all financial penalties previously levied against colleges using one or more applications in addition to the Common Application.  While some high schools and recommenders may express a preference for the Common App, students should have greater flexibility in the application product they choose to submit.  Different applications offer different benefits like the ability to upload personal statements and resumes or to link to online media.  They may also offer different wording or requirements.  Smart students will consider all applications offered by a particular institution and pick the one to submit that best or most accurately represents the credentials they wish colleges to consider.  Note that this year, some colleges offered as many as four different options (including a paper option). 
Look for the Common App to continue announcing changes or improvements for the coming year.  Given the increased competition, the application and its staff will need to become a little more nimble and responsive to stakeholder requests if they want to remain a powerful force in the industry.

May 8, 2015

This year's freshmen give 23 reasons for choosing a college


UCLA

The CIRP (Cooperative Institutional Research Program) Freshman Survey administered by the Higher Education Research Institute (HERI) at UCLA’s Graduate School of Education and Information Studies is the largest and longest-running survey of American college students.

Since 1966, more than 15 million first-time, first-year students at 1,900 have used this forum to respond to an evolving list of questions designed to get at who they are and what they care about.

This
year’s study reflects the attitudes and trends expressed by 153,015 freshmen entering 227 four-year colleges and universities of “varying levels of selectivity and type in the United States."

And not surprisingly, financial considerations continue to exert pressure on incoming freshmen, with college costs and financial aid playing an increasingly decisive role in school-selection.

Although nearly three-quarters (72.7 percent—down from 75.5 percent the previous year) of those surveyed were admitted to their first choice college in 2014, only 55 percent enrolled—the lowest proportion since CIRP first measured the item in 1974.  At the same time, the percentage of students indicating that cost was a “very important” factor in their college-choice process hovered around 45 percent.

In addition, the percentage of students reporting that a financial aid offer was a “very important” factor in their decision to enroll at their current campus came in at just under 47 percent—up from 34 percent in 2004.

Perhaps this is because almost 67 percent have “some” or “major” concerns about their ability to finance a college education.  In fact, a significant of first-year students (14 percent) reported they could not afford their first choice school in 2014.

As a result, students are looking for job-related benefits in their choice of college.  In fact, 86.1 percent of incoming freshmen cited “to be able to get a better job” as a very important reason for enrolling—considerably up from the reported low of 67.8 percent in 1976.

Although academic reputation still weighs heavily in college choice, it’s clear that financial realities may be having a very real effect on the final decision to attend.  And these considerations appear more important than the likelihood that they’ll ever graduate, as less than a third of the survey respondents even considered graduation rates an important factor in their choice of college.

In fact, the CIRP survey probed student awareness of
time it takes to graduate.  Responses indicated that almost 85 percent expect to graduate from the college they had just entered in four years.  This represents a major disconnect between expectations and reality, as the national four-year graduation rate is just over 39 percent.

The following are the 23 reasons for choosing a college students were offered in the UCLA survey. The percentages provided indicate what portion of students surveyed considered these factors "very important."
  1. College has a very good academic reputation (65.4 percent)↑
  2. This college’s graduates get good jobs (53.4 percent)↑
  3. I was offered financial assistance (46.9 percent)↓
  4. The cost of attending this college (44.9 percent)↓
  5. College has a good reputation for social activities (42.8 percent)↓
  6. A visit to the campus (42.4 percent)↓
  7. Wanted to go to a college about this size (36.6 percent)↓
  8. Grads get into good grad/professional schools (32.9 percent)↓
  9. Percent of students that graduate from this college (31.1 percent)↑
  10. Wanted to live near home (20.7 percent)↑
  11. Information from a website (18.8 percent)↑
  12. Rankings in national magazines (18 percent)↑
  13. Parents wanted me to go to this school (17.2 percent)↓
  14. Admitted early decision and/or early action (15.7 percent)↑
  15. Could not afford first choice (14.1 percent)↓
  16. Not offered aid by first choice (10.6 percent)↓
  17. High school counselor advised me (10.4 percent)↑
  18. Athletic department recruited me (9.1 percent)↓
  19. My relatives wanted me to come here (8 percent)↑
  20. Attracted by religious affiliation/orientation of college (7.3 percent)↓
  21. My teacher advised me (7.2 percent)↑
  22. Private college counselor advised me (4.6 percent)↑
  23. Ability to take online courses (4.1 percent)↑
Note that for the fourth consecutive year, the percentage of students describing the role of private college counselors as “very important” increased.

For more information or to download a complete copy of the report, visit the HERI website.

May 6, 2015

Hundreds of really great colleges are still accepting applications for fall 2015 according to NACAC



Ohio Wesleyan University is still accepting applications for fall 2015.

According to the annual National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) College Openings Update published earlier today, nearly 250 colleges and universities still have space available for qualified freshman and/or transfer students for fall 2015. And many of these schools also have financial aid and housing to offer.

Now in its 28th year, the Update is a wonderful search tool for counselors, parents and teachers as they work with students who have not yet completed the college application and admission process.  The listing applies equally for students who may have gotten a late start on their applications as well as for those who weren’t totally satisfied with admissions results received by the May 1 response deadline observed by many colleges.

And there are some amazing opportunities still available.



Locally, Trinity Washington University  and the University of the District of Columbia are still accepting applications from prospective freshmen as well as from transfer students.

In Maryland, Frostburg State University, Hood College, Mount Saint Mary’s, St. Mary’s College of Maryland, Stevenson University, Loyola Maryland University, Notre Dame of Maryland University, St. John’s College, and the University of Maryland Baltimore County (UMBC) indicate they will consider qualified freshman and transfer students.

To the south, Emory and Henry College, Ferrum College, Hollins College, Longwood University, and Randolph College, also show space and resources left for students still looking for fall 2015 placement.

Note that this list is highly fluid.  Over the next several days, colleges will finish reviewing their incoming classes for vacancies and if they want to publicize openings, they will add their names to the Update.  Last year, the list very quickly rose to over 400 colleges and universities.  So keep checking back!

In addition to the NACAC survey, colleges still accepting applications may be found by searching the College Board, Common Application and Universal College Application (UCA) websites (specific instructions are found here). As of  May 6, 2015, the Common App shows 201 members still open to new applicants, and the UCA lists 26 member colleges and universities still accepting first-year and/or transfer students for fall 2015.

The bottom line is that you need to move quickly.  Colleges will only entertain applications as long as they have space available. 

For the most up-to-date information on specific colleges, contact the admissions offices of the schools directly.  You may be surprised how glad they are to hear from you!

May 4, 2015

NACAC’s problem with ‘the question’ extends far beyond the Common Application

Roanoke College uses the Common App to ask "the question."
In an opinion piece he penned for the National Association for College Admission (NACAC) Bulletin, Todd Rinehart, associate chancellor for enrollment and director of admission at the University of Denver and chair of NACAC’s Admission Practices Committee, took a strong stand against the practice of asking candidates where else they applied to college.  

“The philosophy has always been that the college application process is stressful and complex enough, and we don’t need to add yet another layer to the tangled web by posing a question that puts the student in an awkward position.”

In his column, Rinehart singled out the Common Application for taking a hands-off position on the question and suggested that “NACAC members should encourage The Common Application leadership to reconsider this topic—removing the question completely.”

Paul Mott, interim CEO of the Common App, responded forcefully that it wasn’t his responsibility to enforce a rule that’s loosely stated, at best, and seemingly seldom policed as part of the NACAC Statement of Principles of Good Practice (SPGP).

“To me, this is an inappropriate question to put to college applicants, but I am here to serve my Members and any personal opinion I may have is not especially relevant.”

His membership appears to agree.  In fact, no fewer than 63 member colleges and universities ask where else students are applying either within member questions or on the independent writing supplement.  Although the question is almost always “optional,” it still is a routine part of the Common App made available by over ten percent of the membership.

But it turns out that the problem NACAC has with ‘the question’ extends far beyond what is allowable on the Common Application.

In a sample of Common App member colleges and universities, an additional 43 members ask the question on “alternate” applications, including paper and/or other electronic forms accessed on individual college websites.

This brings the total number of members wanting insight into a student’s college list to 106 or over 18 percent of the Common App membership.  And that’s probably a low estimate as many “password protected” applications are difficult to access for review.

But NACAC’s problems don’t end there.  A significant number of these applications crossed the ethical boundaries drawn by the SPGP and made the question appear required.  In other words, the question was not specifically marked as “optional.”  Some also asked applicants to “rank” their choices by listing colleges in order of preference.

More than one NACAC member asked if they were the applicant’s “first choice.”  Other schools asked for a ranking of the first three colleges on the applicant’s list—first, second, and third.

And these are clear violations of NACAC’s SPGP which states that all postsecondary members will “not require or ask candidates or the secondary schools to indicate the order of the candidates’ college or university preferences, except under Early Decision.”

But the issue appears to extend far beyond the Common Application.  A simple scan of NACAC institutional members from Virginia found that out of 34 institutional members, at least 8 colleges that do NOT use the Common Application ask students where else they are applying.  Roanoke and Sweet Briar ask the question on the Common Application, and an additional four Common App members ask it on paper or other electronic versions of their applications.  

This means that at least 14 out of 34 NACAC members in Virginia, or over 40 percent, ask students where else they are applying on one or more of the applications used to assess candidates for admission.

While Rinehart’s words produced a significant hue and cry from NACAC’s college counseling community supporting his stand against the question, institutional members were largely quiet or at least didn’t publicly respond to the challenge to remove these kinds of questions from applications.

And so far, of the three major associations of college counselors, only the Association of College Counselors in Independent Schools (ACCIS) has come forward with a stand against the question.  The other two, IECA and HECA, have not expressed official views or recommended possible changes in the SPGP, to which both organizations require their members to adhere.

As the chairman of NACAC’s Admission Practices Committee, Rinehart has the opportunity to have the issue formally addressed by NACAC’s members—both counseling and institutional.  But if past history is any predictor, don’t expect much in the way of change.  In the age of big data and enrollment forecasting, this particular piece of information may be too important to remove from the process for many NACAC members.

For an updated version of the list of Common App members asking ‘the question,’ email Nancy@CollegeExplorations.com